What common misconceptions do people have about car safety?

Apr 28, 2024

Leave a message

1. The thicker the car skin, the safer it will be. The thickness of the car skin will affect the damage caused by small collisions, which will in turn affect the repair costs. It will also affect the sound insulation and sense of class of the entire vehicle, but it is really not important for protecting the safety of passengers. What matters to passengers is the strength of the steel frame to keep the car intact after a collision.


2. The heavier the car, the safer it is.
Other things remaining unchanged, an increase in vehicle weight will actually reduce the handling limit and braking performance, making it even more unsafe. To take an extreme example, can a car be safer simply by putting more bricks in the car? One of the two cars in the same class is lighter and the other is heavier. This may be because the latter is not lightweight enough or has a steel frame. The strength is not good enough and we have to make it stronger, which often does not mean that the latter is the safest. In fact, the Golf 79, one of the most outstanding A-class cars in terms of safety, is also the lightest.
For two vehicles with the same crash scores, the heavier vehicle is indeed generally safer. In the crash test, because it hits a wall, the impact force is proportional to the weight. Therefore, the same safety cage deforms, and the heavy vehicle withstands greater impact force. In most collision accidents, the impact force on the heavy vehicle and the light vehicle is the same, so the heavier vehicle has an advantage. In addition, the acceleration of heavy vehicles after impact is smaller, and the possibility of occupant injuries will also be reduced.


3.SUVs are safer than cars.
When driving an SUV in urban areas, compared with ordinary rear-end collisions on the highway, it is true that the high position will take advantage. Having a high field of vision and seeing far away is also an advantage. However, a major disadvantage of SUVs when driving at medium and high speeds is that because of their high center of gravity, they are more likely to roll over when driving in curves, and the fatality rate of rollovers is the highest, especially in places where there is a lot of rain and snow. The SUV platform of the same price range is often one level lower than that of sedans of the same price range, which sometimes reflects the safety design. Generally speaking, the safety of SUVs and sedans of the same price range is actually about the same. Many people think that SUVs look thick and thick. SUVs are safer, but in fact this has no impact as mentioned in the two points above.

 

4. The smaller the deformation of the entire vehicle after a collision, the better the safety of the vehicle.
In fact, good safety should be when the front of the car fully collapses to absorb energy, but the cab remains intact. If it is all intact, without the car to absorb energy, people will have to absorb more kinetic energy of the collision, which is actually more unsafe. .

 

5. The simple configuration of anti-collision steel beams 9 shows the manufacturer's disregard for consumer safety.
The main function of anti-collision steel beams is to reduce damage to the car body in low-speed collisions, which is meaningful for reducing the repair costs of small collisions, but has no effect on medium- and high-speed collisions that truly threaten passengers.

 

6. American cars are safe, but Japanese cars are not.
Generally speaking, the safest low-priced cars in the world are Honda and Subaru, both of which are Japanese. The IHS small offset crash test is better than that of Mercedes-Benz and BMW. However, the most unsafe cars are Nissan and Suzuki. Generally speaking, looking at iihs data, among affordable cars, the first-tier cars are Honda and Subaru, and the second-tier cars are Volkswagen, Ford, Hyundai, Dodge, Mazda, Mitsubishi, and Toyota (Toyota's latest models actually have good collision scores, but When it first came out of the small offset collision, the performance was poor, and it was suspected of taking the test. The advantage is that it improves quickly, but the disadvantage is that it may reduce materials in aspects that are not reflected in the test). The third gear is Chevrolet and Nissan (Nissan is characterized by Sylphy The safety of the following cars is very poor, but the safety of Teana and above is good), Suzuki. On average, in fact, German, Korean, and Japanese models are better, but American models are slightly worse.
However, the domestic market is somewhat different. Domestic Japanese and Korean models (Japanese models are mainly Toyota and Nissan small cars, Honda is not included) may be less strict than the international market due to insufficient safety standards and consumers' lack of safety knowledge. Although the German models have fewer safety configurations, because a large number of old models have not been updated, the general safety status is worse than in the international market. American models do have relatively generous safety configurations in the domestic market, especially Ford, so they are relatively better. However, in general, the various car series are still similar, and you should mainly consider the specific model and brand.

 

7. Sedan cars are safer than hatchback cars. Many people feel that hatchbacks have poor rear-end protection. There is actually no difference. Hatchbacks generally have particularly reinforced rear ends, so in many cases even though the body is short, they are heavier than sedans of the same platform, which can make up for the disadvantage of a small buffer distance. The real problem is the third row of three-row MPVs and SUVs. Because various tests lack measurement of the third row, the protection is very questionable. If you must buy a three-row MPV with a full-size design, the third row has more space and the distance to the rear is longer after all three rows are occupied, so it may be better.

 

8. Active safety is more important than passive safety
Many people on the Internet say that active safety can prevent accidents and is more useful than passive safety that is used to reduce accident damage after an accident occurs. Therefore, many people will give priority to ESP over side airbags or cars with better overall collision performance. This statement is not entirely correct.
When driving in urban areas, the most dangerous accidents are often caused by you not paying attention or the other person not paying attention. When a car collides vertically with another car at an intersection, you generally cannot avoid it, and active safety cannot take effect at all. Side curtain airbags and good frame rigidity would be helpful.
When driving on the highway, in most cases there is a danger. The correct approach is to brake and hit the vehicle, rather than turning the steering wheel suddenly (even with ESP, it is still easy to roll over). At this time, good frame rigidity, and head The configuration of head air curtain 9 and knee airbags is also more effective than ESP.
For medium-speed emergency avoidance, ESP is helpful, but even in such a situation, if you change the lane rashly, you may still hit the car on the side, causing greater damage. In this case, priority should still be given to applying the brakes. If there are frontal airbags, everyone in the car has seat belts, and the child is sitting in a safety seat, it is basically impossible to cause any harm to the occupants in a direct collision in the city.
What is the biggest advantage of ESP is that it can prevent the car body from slipping in rain or snow. For some areas in the north, this impact is indeed great, and ESP should be given priority. But the driving environment is definitely not more important for everyone in all areas.
In general, both are important. If conditions permit, you should at least choose a model with both ESP and side airbags.